Madden 2010 News Post

Madden NFL 10 Ratings: Top 10 by Position (ESPN Videogames)

06:32 PM - May 26, 2009 by iamemmittsmith

ESPN Videogames have posted the top 10 players by position in Madden NFL 10.

Game: Madden NFL 10Reader Score: 7.5/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3 / Wii / Xbox 360Votes for game: 76 - View All

Madden NFL 10 Videos

Member Comments

# 21 gr18 @ 05/26/09 07:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shotgun styles


	AS USUAL TOM BRADY IS MASSIVELY OVERRATED! Tom's throw power should be 90 or 92. Manning's throw power should be 93 at best.

yeah,I'd put Peyton's throw power down a point or two and probably Carson Palmer's also.

# 22 GoGiaNTS25 @ 05/26/09 08:03 PM

westbrook has 99 agility and 99 elusiveness? isnt that a little too much or am i just too much of a homer?

# 23 Glorious Arc @ 05/26/09 08:05 PM

Didnt they have a debate about Brady VS Manning on total access? They said that they thought Manning was the better QB because he had both a stronger arm and a more accurate arm?

DOWN WITH TOM BRADY

I was surprized to see Rivers with an 81. I dont follow much of his play but I would have thought it was stronger. If he is an 81 I am starting to think that Penningtons will be either 70 or in the 60s. Who would have thought some people would end up using a QB with a 60ish arm strength lol(just guessing here)

# 24 Thirty3 Degrees @ 05/26/09 08:08 PM

Roddy White is rated too high.

# 25 Glorious Arc @ 05/26/09 08:13 PM

Found the video...

http://www.nfl.com/videos/indianapol...nning-or-Brady

DOWN WITH BRADY

# 26 gr18 @ 05/26/09 08:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glorious Arc


	Didnt they have a debate about Brady VS Manning on total access? They said that they thought Manning was the better QB because he had both a stronger arm and a more accurate arm? DOWN WITH TOM BRADY I was surprized to see Rivers with an 81. I dont follow much of his play but I would have thought it was stronger. If he is an 81 I am starting to think that Penningtons will be either 70 or in the 60s. Who would have thought some people would end up using a QB with a 60ish arm strength lol(just guessing here)

If there was a wider range with some of the other qb's I could see it but Rivers arm strength should be at least 85-87,comparable to Brees.There's no way he should be 16 below Brady.

I'm surprised Brady isn't higher in the short and medium accuracy but long accuracy and obviously arm strength are off.

# 27 Hooe @ 05/26/09 08:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shotgun styles


	AS USUAL TOM BRADY IS MASSIVELY OVERRATED! Tom's throw power should be 90 or 92. Manning's throw power should be 93 at best.

Please tell me who in the NFL is better than Brady, who has three Super Bowl rings (more than any quarterback currently playing by my recall), led the Pats to a perfect season in 2007, has the fourth-best quarterback rating amongst all active quarterbacks (behind Peyton, Romo, and Warner), has a 2.30 : 1 TD to INT ratio...

I could go on but Tom Brady's numbers and results speak for themselves and don't need my defense to stand up on their own. By no means is he "massively overrated" or even overrated. He and Peyton are unquestionably the top two quarterbacks in the league right now, and I don't see how an argument can be made otherwise.

# 28 mwjr @ 05/26/09 08:15 PM

In the RBs category, what does 'BCV' stand for?
EDIT: Never mind. Saw the key at the bottom. It means 'Ball Carrier Vision.'

# 29 glitchditcher @ 05/26/09 08:23 PM

-Peyton Manning should not have 99 AWR and his arm is not stronger than McNabbs.
-Brady's accuracy ratings are ALL too low. 90 MEDIUM !? I like how they gave him the 97 THP though.
-Rivers THP is a bit low and his speed is way too high.
-AD with the 69 CAR rating ? Woww. He's bad, but... idk.
-Tomlinson hasn't fumbled in 2 years. 87 CAR ? should be 99.
-Westbrook's AGI is NOT a 99 anymore.
-Fitz is way overrated. 99 RR ? no. 99 CIT ? no.
-Ed Reed's man coverage is too high.
-Patrick Willis' strength is too high. Like his realistic coverage ratings, though.

# 30 jbooc13 @ 05/26/09 08:25 PM

Philip rivers should have an equal or perferably stronger arm than brees

# 31 Sanchez_Mareno @ 05/26/09 08:26 PM

All hail Tom Brady.

# 32 4solo @ 05/26/09 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thirty3 Degrees


	Roddy White is rated too high.

Hell yea i totally agree; Roddy White is def not better than T.O.

# 33 edreedpicksix @ 05/26/09 08:38 PM

woot they fixed ed reeds visor in 09 he always had a purple one for some reason

and only two players have 99 play recogniton ed reed and ray lewis !! oo yaa

# 34 AC IS ART @ 05/26/09 08:39 PM

I for the most part love the ratings. I like the player models too (Nmandi actually looks like...Nmandi). But please for the love of god turn down Westbrook's AGI/SPD/ELU. He gets my respect, but 06' Tomlinson status he is not...

# 35 cowboyscowboys @ 05/26/09 08:45 PM

Nmandi Aso is to fast for the toned down ratings, should be a 92 at the most.

Antonio Gates 85 speed Jason Witten 75 speed B.S. straight up.

# 36 Lava @ 05/26/09 08:51 PM

I would've liked to see Chris Johnson at RB and Bo Scaife at TE for my Titans, but I suppose the roster updates will take care of that.

It's dumb that they didn't do O-line, every defensive position, and special teams, though.

# 37 Glorious Arc @ 05/26/09 08:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shotgun styles


	From a hyperbolic perspective all NFL QBs are overrated. But my statement is about Brady being overrated in this game. HE DOES NOT HAVE A BIG ARM. Period. He's a touch passer, and his ratings should reflect that. He's a 90-92 arm strength guy and that's being generous. Real world he's probably an 88-89.

+1

If I were an NFL QB and had stats like Brady I would have a 97+ throw power too....Yet for some strange reason I cant throw the ball further/harder then Palmer, Cutler, or Russel. Just because you produce doesnt mean you have a strong arm.

# 38 JaSnake16 @ 05/26/09 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by T9R


	Ray Lewis a 97?

Attribute that one to EA being famous for rating players as they ONCE WERE. Not players as they are NOW.

# 39 Nza @ 05/26/09 09:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by salbowski


	Am i the only 1 that's gets pissed off that "defense" get stuck as 1 position?? The steelers didn't win the superbowl cos of their offense last year.

Well, technically they kind of did on that final drive, but I agree with your point. Mainstream = offense > defense, which always annoys me a little.

# 40 Sanchez_Mareno @ 05/26/09 09:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shotgun styles


	Brady is The Cake. And as everyone knows, The Cake is a lie...

Brady is the best qb in the league.

« Previous 123 4 5 6 7 8 9…16 17 Next »

More Links

Madden NFL 10 Ratings: Top 10 by Position (ESPN Videogames)