Home
MLB 2K9 News Post

The Major League Baseball 2K9 is now available. Please post your impressions here.

Major League Baseball 2K9 screenshot gallery - Click to view
Game: Major League Baseball 2K9Reader Score: 6/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3 / Xbox 360Votes for game: 38 - View All
Major League Baseball 2K9 Videos
Member Comments
# 461 jerm21 @ 02/24/09 08:44 PM
wow. from what i see it every single one of you dislike the game so far.

Don't you guys realize how crummy last years game was, and how much of an improvement it is this year? It was 2k baseball's rebuilding year, they are starting in a new direction with the animations, the announcers, the real time atmosphere, I mean give them a break.

It's only gonna get better. All that matters is its a solid baseball game. Better than last years, I'll be getting it. And if there are things I don't like about it, that is what the 2k10 Wishlist forum will be used for.
 
# 462 dave_sz @ 02/24/09 08:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by StatMan79
In four games played:

I had a much better time pitching than I did hitting. Hitting is still very frustrating to me and I'm apparently really bad at pitch recognition.
Just hold up on teh left stick and if you see anything higher than middle of the plate, swing. You'll get hits left and right...
 
# 463 dave_sz @ 02/24/09 09:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jerm21
wow. from what i see it every single one of you dislike the game so far.

Don't you guys realize how crummy last years game was, and how much of an improvement it is this year? It was 2k baseball's rebuilding year, they are starting in a new direction with the animations, the announcers, the real time atmosphere, I mean give them a break.

It's only gonna get better. All that matters is its a solid baseball game. Better than last years, I'll be getting it. And if there are things I don't like about it, that is what the 2k10 Wishlist forum will be used for.
So we're supposed to cut them some slack because they are rebuilding? If that was the case why didn't they just skip this year and release the 2k10 beast next year? Or maybe they should give us a discount since according to you, this is only a half finished product...
 
# 464 Brooklynnets24 @ 02/24/09 09:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jerm21
wow. from what i see it every single one of you dislike the game so far.

Don't you guys realize how crummy last years game was, and how much of an improvement it is this year? It was 2k baseball's rebuilding year, they are starting in a new direction with the animations, the announcers, the real time atmosphere, I mean give them a break.

It's only gonna get better. All that matters is its a solid baseball game. Better than last years, I'll be getting it. And if there are things I don't like about it, that is what the 2k10 Wishlist forum will be used for.
saying that this game game is an improvement from 2K8 is not sayign anything at all... and is this game really gonna get better? how many years do these guys need?
 
# 465 dave_sz @ 02/24/09 09:16 PM
Is there a way to pre-load throws? Seems like I have to catch a ball before I can start the meter to throw it again which cause a delay in the action. It's pretty much throw wait for the catch then do the throw meter then finally animation to throw again...
 
# 466 Big Business @ 02/24/09 09:17 PM
I liked what I saw for the most part on the demo. I think with the community tweaking some things around and taking some things off that annoy me, like that "very early swing" arcade feedback I think it can be a good game.

I know it's not "the show", which I have never played because I have a 360....but it's what we haveand I think it is better than last year.

The other thing I am hoping is that they said the worked a lot on the franchise aspect of the game and if that is real solid then all the other little things I can over look.

Baserunning sucks in the demo since they dont tell you how to do it.
 
# 467 AceTitan @ 02/24/09 09:20 PM
Well since all I have is the Xbox, I think this game was leaps and bounds better. I think this game will be fun. So quit all you haters. 2k8 was garbage to this game.
 
# 468 CarryTheWeight @ 02/24/09 09:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jerm21
wow. from what i see it every single one of you dislike the game so far.
That's not the case. I'm enjoying it, as are many others in this post. No, the game isn't amazing, but it's far from awful. I think people just need to take it for what it is: a rebuilt game by a first-year developer.
 
# 469 Brooklynnets24 @ 02/24/09 09:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dave_sz
Is there a way to pre-load throws? Seems like I have to catch a ball before I can start the meter to throw it again which cause a delay in the action. It's pretty much throw wait for the catch then do the throw meter then finally animation to throw again...
yea i have the same problem hopefully its fixed
 
# 470 fistofrage @ 02/24/09 09:31 PM
How are you guys getting the demo? It says unavailable to me and I'm a gold member.
 
# 471 Brooklynnets24 @ 02/24/09 09:33 PM
 
# 472 nymets3000 @ 02/24/09 09:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fistofrage
How are you guys getting the demo? It says unavailable to me and I'm a gold member.
Same here, it's a pain in the ***. If you notice there is no picture and the 2k9 cover is on the 2k7 demo for some reason.
 
# 473 B_rad13 @ 02/24/09 09:42 PM
Why is there no Demo download for the PS3??
 
# 474 Full_Collapse @ 02/24/09 09:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by B_rad13
Why is there no Demo download for the PS3??
Okay so it's not just me, I went to the store expecting to see it and didn't find it.
 
# 475 dawhiteshark6969 @ 02/24/09 09:51 PM
i use to have a ps 3 and the show 08 and this 2k9 game ****in sucks compared to the show. i was not impressed with the demo at all.
 
# 476 JoshCA916 @ 02/24/09 09:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JonahFalcon
Throwing glitch - slow grounder, the fielder will grab it... and hold it, and the throwing meter won't appear.

This is an example of trying to inject minigames within the game where it doesn't belong.

JUST HAVE THE FIELDER THROW IT.

Stop with the meters. Stop with the analog. Get the game RIGHT first.

A player shouldn't commit an error because the gamer didn't throw on the meter. A player should commit an error because he made an error even if the gamer did it perfectly. That's the definition of AN ERROR.
man everytime i read something you post it's like somebody is running their finger nails acrossed the chalk board. we all know you are having issues with the game good for you, but saying why do they have analog controlls they are stupid every time you post is pretty much trolling. hate to tell you but most people prefer analog to just pushing a button that's why they play this game, just get over yourself and play it for what it's worth, and yes it's just a demo, not finished. if you don't like the game stop playing it and stop posting in this thread/forum
 
# 477 jeffy777 @ 02/24/09 09:59 PM
Quote:
This is pro difficulty so yeah. What do people expect?
Quote:
Originally Posted by JonahFalcon
I expect a demo to show what I can expect from a game.

If your demo does not reflect the game, DON'T RELEASE THE DEMO.
It does reflect the game.....on an EASY difficulty level.
 
# 478 seveb @ 02/24/09 10:01 PM
Well, just got done playing a couple games, so here we go...

Obvious, but gotta say it - I love the announcing. I don't know how well it would hold up through hours of gameplay, but I'm very impressed thus far. The TV-style presentation is a great idea. They've a ways to go to really make this work, but it seems like a great start. The pitching mechanism seems fun, and perhaps is a bit more challenging on higher levels than the demo.

However, for me the meat of any game is the batter/pitcher duel. I feel it comes up a bit short here. The ball looks like a helium-filled grapefruit as it approaches the plate. While I'm batting, I get the sense I'm playing a mini-game or something rather than locked in an intense battle.

While I feel the presentation style holds much promise, the camera cuts lose something when the players look and move as if they've been lobotomized. And I'm a gameplay over graphics guy every time, but these dudes look funny.

I understand the depths from which this franchise has had to resurrect itself, and this by no means seems like a total stinker. Style-wise, some seeds have been planted that may bear more fruit in the future. But for now, the core gameplay is a "meh".
 
# 479 dave_sz @ 02/24/09 10:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoshCA916
man everytime i read something you post it's like somebody is running their finger nails acrossed the chalk board. we all know you are having issues with the game good for you, but saying why do they have analog controlls they are stupid every time you post is pretty much trolling. hate to tell you but most people prefer analog to just pushing a button that's why they play this game, just get over yourself and play it for what it's worth, and yes it's just a demo, not finished. if you don't like the game stop playing it and stop posting in this thread/forum
and everytime I read how much better using the analog is or how old school pressing the button is I feel the same way you do. Guess what, you still push the stick(button). Even though I like the stick hitting its just a pointless additional step. Instead of pushing one button once I have to push one button twice. It's not like the stick is harder or even innovative. Pull it back whenever you want and then just push up. Whooptee doo...

PS Can't wait for the game...
 
# 480 Rob_NYY @ 02/24/09 10:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoshCA916
hate to tell you but most people prefer analog to just pushing a button that's why they play this game
Actually, most 360 users play this game because they have no choice. It's the only real baseball game they can get.

And Jonah has every write to post his impressions of the demo here in the impressions thread. This isn't the "come in and praise the MLB 2K9 demo" thread. It's a thread for people to post what they are seeing with the demo.

Mr. Jonah Falcon is gracing us with his presence here. We should show him the respect he deserves!

Talkin' Yankees rules, Jonah!
 


Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.