12 or 13 pitchers?

[abclefty12]

Carrying 13 pitchers or an 8 man bullpen seems to be an up and coming trend in baseball these days. I'm starting my franchise tonight and I'm curious what you all do. For those of you who do a fair share of simming in your franchise, have you noticed much of an impact either way?

[trackstar121388]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I typically start my franchise with the same roster my team has, the Cubs are my team and they have an 8 man bullpen so that's what I'll be using.

[underdog13]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I go with 11 usually [emoji51]

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

[bravo2208]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I didn't know that was becoming a trend. I normally carry 1 long guy, 3 middle relievers, a lefty and righty setup man, and a closer. What are the benefits of 13?

[Frostball]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I always go with 12
I try to have one long guy
3 middle
2 setup lefty righty
And a closer


Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports

[abclefty12]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I didn't know that was becoming a trend. I normally carry 1 long guy, 3 middle relievers, a lefty and righty setup man, and a closer. What are the benefits of 13?

Teams seem to be pushing starters less to go deeper into games and favoring individual matchups more out of the pen. Limited bat options off the bench require more versatile players that can play more positions which seems to also be popular.

By the way, not sure if the Braves started the season this way, but they were considering an 8 man bullpen earlier this year: https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.mlb...-2018.amp.html


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[bravo2208]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

Thanks for the explanation. The Braves have a lot of moving pieces right now and things feel tentative. They opened the season with an 8-man pen. 7 are still there and Luke Jackson has been added since. Right now it's at 9 since we haven't had to use a 5. Anibal Sanchez has been coming out of the pen and will likely be joining the rotation this weekend. Things will change again once Camargo, Gohara, and Flowers come back. But for the time being it looks like 8 is the number Snitker is going with.

[Caulfield]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

12 for current rosters & 11 for 1980's rosters.

But really, each season you just need to find 2 relievers with at least 1 option apiece that dont figure into your long-term plans, & just constantly shuttle 'em back & forth from Triple AAA & the Show. Yeah, you might hurt your farm club's chances of winning but the minors function isn't to win anyways. That way you can in reality field a 26-man roster.

[Jr.]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I like keeping 13 pitchers, but it means I need a lot of position players with versatility. So sometimes it takes a year or some trades to get that set up.

[LowerWolf]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I’m old enough to remember when teams had five-man bullpens, so eight seems excessive.

I go with 12 pitchers (seven in the pen).

[Sumodeads]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I always go with 12
I try to have one long guy
3 middle
2 setup lefty righty
And a closer


Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports

This is the way I always like to do it as well

[wisdom less13]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

I've usually kept a starter as a swing/long man, and seven other guys. There comes a time in every franchise where I have to call up another starter and keep him there for a bit. Sometimes it's because of extra innings, or from my bullpen being shoved into lockers on a nightly basis...

[Unlucky 13]

Re: 12 or 13 pitchers?

If I'm really comfortable with my staff, I'll go with as few as 5 relievers. Otherwise, usually I go with 6.