Design Your Own Plays

[ednaaard]

This isn't a "why isn't this in Madden 17", or a "I can't believe this was omitted" thread, please leave Madden 17 out of it, I just wanna generate some discussion and see what the feasibility of this ever occurring is. Was it ever a thing in previous Maddens?

How could would it be to be able to design runs and blocking schemes. I understand that this would totally cheese online play as it would be very difficult to implement without it being taken advantage of I would imagine, but imagine the possibility of this being in CFM or Play Now.

[Jr.]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

There was a play designer in previous Maddens. I don't remember the last one that had it, but it was fairly basic. You picked one of the existing formations and designed the play from there. The blocking selections were standard (pass block, run block middle/left/right), and you would select the routes for WRs on pass plays.

[drewst18]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

It was a thing, I know back in 08 they had the feature. The game is available on PC and has amazing modders that keep the game current.

It was great but very basic. You could create a playbook from scratch including your own formations. I loved it and not sure why it was taken out. I loved making crazy formations like 4 wide 1 TE and the 4 WR all lineup in a straight vertical line or a full house type with RB1 and RB2 and my FB1 and pound the ball. Would have a speed and power back it was a blast.

Now a days with online being so crucial to games they would have to make it so that you can't play with your own online as the cheese was too strong. There was no blocking schemes but you could set pulling guards and such but nothing too complex.

Here is a video of create a play including custom formation -

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCSgTGHl5yM

[Mav3rek7]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

This isn't a "why isn't this in Madden 17", or a "I can't believe this was omitted" thread, please leave Madden 17 out of it, I just wanna generate some discussion and see what the feasibility of this ever occurring is. Was it ever a thing in previous Maddens?

How could would it be to be able to design runs and blocking schemes. I understand that this would totally cheese online play as it would be very difficult to implement without it being taken advantage of I would imagine, but imagine the possibility of this being in CFM or Play Now.

Not sure that it was Madden, but I do remember a football game back in the day that would let you design your own plays. You could have a custom playbook and design from scratch both offensive and defensive plays. I used to run around with a note pad where I had drawn out my own playbook and then translated those plays into the play editor. It was a fun option to have.

[BreakingBad2013]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

I'd rather see blocking hot routes. Where if you pickup a blitz you have more time, or if you miss it's a very quick sack.

[ThatMichiganFan]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

I'm not sure if this was in previous Maddens, but as a sim head, I would love to be able to create my own concepts and plays. If such a thing were to be implemented, it would have to be CFM only, because I have a feeling people would find a way to abuse it online quickly.

Maybe it could be a part of the offseason, when coaches typically add new schemes to their playbook. It could be a stage where you could add new custom plays, maybe even custom formations.

[Mav3rek7]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

This isn't a "why isn't this in Madden 17", or a "I can't believe this was omitted" thread, please leave Madden 17 out of it, I just wanna generate some discussion and see what the feasibility of this ever occurring is. Was it ever a thing in previous Maddens?

How could would it be to be able to design runs and blocking schemes. I understand that this would totally cheese online play as it would be very difficult to implement without it being taken advantage of I would imagine, but imagine the possibility of this being in CFM or Play Now.

Looks like it may have been Madden '05.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCSgTGHl5yM

[ednaaard]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

Looks like it may have been Madden '05.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCSgTGHl5yM

That looks exactly how I imagined it.

I would absolutely love something like this in CFM.

[underdog13]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

Madden 03 was the first year they had it. Lasted till the end of the ps2 era

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

[howboutdat]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

Looks like it may have been Madden '05.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCSgTGHl5yM

Ahhh yeah, i remember this, it was awesome fun trying to create a play and run it out to see how it plays out on the field. Miss that.

[Datninja619]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

IF they brought this back, I wouldn't want it allowed in Ranked games (including MUT Ranked games) and a toggle option for CFM.

It's bad enough people find stock plays and do audibles that exploit AI.

[T4VERTS]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

The issues really do come down to working within the framework of the AI. If people can build plays that by the very design isn't necessarily football sound but Madden defeating it kills the game. I think in concept it sounds cool in implementation it becomes a bit of a nightmare.

[howboutdat]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

The issues really do come down to working within the framework of the AI. If people can build plays that by the very design isn't necessarily football sound but Madden defeating it kills the game. I think in concept it sounds cool in implementation it becomes a bit of a nightmare.

Yeah its def better suited for offline cfm only no doubt.

[briax87]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

Madden 03 was the first year they had it. Lasted till the end of the ps2 era

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

I used this so much in Madden 03. Spent weeks on end designing ridiculous offensive plays and formations, would love to have it back in again

[Brightline]

Re: Design Your Own Plays

Would be nice to at least "save hot routes" as new plays. I think this would also allow a more realistic hot route system which limits hot routes (perhaps to 0-2 per play depending on QB awareness and/or OC)