The booth called for a review in the first quarter?

[rook2121]

Playin my franchise and threw a touchdown, then it goes to review, they musta thought my player dropped the ball, but after review he didn't but then the opposing team didn't get charged a timeout? Soo I'm confused, they challenged it with 1:12 left in the 1st quarter

[roadman]

The booth now challenges all questionable TD calls in the NFL.

Sounds like a realistic challenge to me.

[stp2081]

Well technically they review all TDs now, but nobody's really gonna doubt the extremely obvious ones.

[Champion8877]

Quote: Originally Posted by rook2121

Playin my franchise and threw a touchdown, then it goes to review, they musta thought my player dropped the ball, but after review he didn't but then the opposing team didn't get charged a timeout? Soo I'm confused, they challenged it with 1:12 left in the 1st quarter

well no **** they didnt get charged a timeout...they didnt review it. if the booth reviews they arent going to take a timeout away from the other team. for what? you do know you only lose a timeout if YOU lose the challenge, not if the booth loses the challenge

[goravens2052]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

The booth now challenges all questionable TD calls in the NFL. Sounds like a realistic challenge to me.

yep sounds good to me but still the Challenge System is Broken.

[roadman]

Interesting, I'm hearing it's working better after the last patch, but I haven't had a challenge lately.

That OP's original statement isn't a broken one on that play.

I have seen some weird calls though, like calling for a challenge for fumble and the challenge comes up for spot of the ball.

That part needs to be fixed, that's frustrating.

[kashmir28]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

Interesting, I'm hearing it's working better after the last patch, but I haven't had a challenge lately. That OP's original statement isn't a broken one on that play. I have seen some weird calls though, like calling for a challenge for fumble and the challenge comes up for spot of the ball. That part needs to be fixed, that's frustrating.

That may explain why several resent challenges I've experienced seemed more accurate than what I've experienced in the past.

I can only imagine the coding necessary to implement a replay/challenge system in sports titles and shocked that EA actually had this rule change available for this year's Madden.

[packerfan28]

I had a touchdown pass caught by my tightend Jared cook Jr. get overturned. His 2nd foot touched on the white line so it was out of bounds. I never knew they implemented that in the game but I thought it was cool when it happened.