McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders - Operation Sports Forums

McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mcgibblets82
    Rookie
    • Sep 2017
    • 482

    #1

    McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

    If you are looking for a doable (mostly) Coach Mode experience, give these sliders a shot.

    Before trying these sliders, let me tell you what these sliders are not. These sliders were not created with the intention of reflecting real life college football stats. These sliders were created with the game's sim engine in mind. You will not get realistic season long stats with these sliders. The goal of these sliders is to get season long stats that are comparable to the results from the rest of the simmed games in your dynasty, not real life.

    Also, there are some house rules to use with these sliders that are needed for coach mode to be viable, or at least a version of coach mode anyway. These sliders are not perfect. Obviously, if we could do true coach mode that would be preferred. EA didn't give us that option, so we just have to do the best we can with what we've got. If you aren't comfortable using these house rules, feel free to not use them. They are merely suggestions or guidelines. Play how you want. This is how I play and I enjoy it. I just want to share my experience.

    Feel free to leave your thoughts about the sliders. Constructive feedback is always appreciated. Disrespectful and unnecessary comments will just be ignored. I have far too many other things to do than engage with that kind of stuff. In general, just be nice.



    Game and Slider Settings

    Main Menu
    (Be sure to import these into Dynasty and adjust the penalties inside dynasty as detailed further down in this post)

    Game Settings:

    If something isn't listed here, then it's the default setting being used.

    Skill Level - All American
    Quarter Length - 11 Minutes
    Accelerated Clock - On
    Minimum Play Clock Time – 20 Seconds

    Passing Type: PLACEMENT or CLASSIC (I prefer placement)


    Injuries - 50
    Fatigue - 60
    Min Player Speed Threshold - 83


    Penalties

    Offside - 60
    False Start - 99
    Holding - 55
    Face Mask - 35
    Defensive Pass Interference - 35
    Illegal Block In The Back - 50
    Roughing Passer - 35
    Intentional Grounding - Off
    Roughing the Kicker - Off
    Running into the Kicker - Off
    Everything else - On


    Gameplay Sliders:


    User/CPU
    QB Accuracy - 31
    Pass Blocking - 68
    WR Catching - 36
    Run Blocking - 50/100
    Fumbles - 40
    Pass Defense Reaction Time - 60
    Interceptions - 20
    Pass Coverage - 60
    Tackling – 42

    Special Teams
    FG Power - 50
    FG Accuracy - 37
    Punt Power - 58
    Punt Accuracy - 40
    Kickoff Power – 50


    DYNASTY SETTINGS

    Skill Level - All American
    Coach Firing - On
    Coach XP Speed Setting - Slowest (User Choice)
    Player Edit Permission - Any Player
    Injury - On
    Wear and Tear - On

    Clock Management:
    Quarter Length - 11 Minutes
    Accelerated Clock - On
    Minimum Play Clock Time - 20 Seconds


    User Team Help:
    Season Experience - Full Control
    League Advancement - Manual

    Team Settings:
    Auto Recruiting - Off
    User Coach Auto Progression - Off


    Gameplay Sliders:

    Import sliders from Main Menu

    Adjust the following sliders inside dynasty:
    Offside 62
    Holding 53
    Roughing the Passer 34

    AUTO SUBS
    Possibly the most important part of this set. Set ALL POSITIONS to 80 Sub In and 60 Sub out. If you'll notice, the default auto subs in the main menu are different from the default auto subs inside dynasty. Set them to 80/60 for ALL POSITIONS in both the main menu and inside dynasty.

    One exception I make is to the HB position. I have mine set at 95 sub in and 92 sub out. I like the rotations it gives me at running back. This is completely personal preference. Leave it at 80/60 if you want to manually rotate your running backs. Again, if you make this change, change it in both the main menu and inside dynasty.




    HOUSE RULES

    1. No controlling players. This should be obvious, being that we are playing Coach Mode. Call your plays and make all your adjustments at the line of scrimmage, but no controlling of the players. There are two exceptions. See them listed below:
    1. Exception 1 – I will scramble my QB manually either straight up the field or at a forward angle towards the sideline. No special moves allowed and only running until tackled, forced to slide, throw the ball away, or run out of bounds. ALL of the following conditions must be met before running:

      1. All my receivers have completed their routes and are now just running to get open

      2. The QB is just hanging onto the ball for no apparent reason

      3. The defense is giving the QB an obvious lane to run with the ball. If the pocket is collapsing on my QB and there’s nowhere to run, I won’t run backwards to get out of the pocket. I just take the sack. Sideways and forward only.


    2. Exception 2 – I will manually throw the ball on HB Screen plays. Otherwise, it’s essentially an automatic sack. Choose your screen plays wisely though, because the CPU generally plays the screens well. You could still get sacked anyway or they could stuff the RB.


    2. On defense, I control a single player and do not switch. The player you choose is up to you. My personal preference is to use a DT. I generally will choose the DT on the same side the cpu RB is lining up, or whichever one is closest to the actual middle of the field if the RB is behind the QB. Occasionally I will use a DE. I no longer hold L1 on my controller until the play has ended. You can hold L1 if you wish, but I feel like it gives my player an advantage over the cpu. That could just be placebo effect. I'm not entirely sure to be honest. My choice is to not hold L1 though.

    3. For all read and triple option plays, I use player lock on my RB. Otherwise, the QB never keeps the ball on the read option. For other option plays, he will pitch it and player lock is not necessary. I realize the player lock camera is less than ideal. But it is what it is. Not much we can do about it. Don't use player lock if you don't like the camera.

    4. I generally do most of my own special teams plays. I used to slow sim most of them, but got tired of the cpu going for it when I didn't want them to go for it. For really long field goals, I will still slow sim those, especially if I'm fairly confident they won't go for it.



    XP Sliders – Feel free to use whatever you'd like.
    Last edited by Mcgibblets82; 12-10-2024, 02:12 PM. Reason: Version 5 (12/10)
  • BungerHenry
    Rookie
    • Jul 2004
    • 98

    #2
    Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

    I will give these a try this weekend and give feedback. I've been playing coach mode for over 20 years in this series and I've been looking for some decent sliders for this entry.

    Comment

    • nxt
      H**sm*n
      • Jun 2003
      • 1886

      #3
      Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

      Question: Does adjusting Holding to 58 affect the gameplay or is it just to get more holding calls?

      Comment

      • tessl
        All Star
        • Apr 2007
        • 5648

        #4
        Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

        I noticed you set speed threshold to 85. What exactly does that do?

        Comment

        • Mcgibblets82
          Rookie
          • Sep 2017
          • 482

          #5
          Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

          Originally posted by nxt
          Question: Does adjusting Holding to 58 affect the gameplay or is it just to get more holding calls?

          The holding slider is pretty sensitive in terms of number of holding calls that get called. Even at 58 it feels like those ticky tack holding calls get called sometimes. But I found lower than 58 you don’t get that many holding calls at all. Once you start getting towards 60 you really start seeing a lot of holding calls.


          Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

          Comment

          • Mcgibblets82
            Rookie
            • Sep 2017
            • 482

            #6
            Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

            Originally posted by tessl
            I noticed you set speed threshold to 85. What exactly does that do?

            This lowers the amount of distance between the fastest and slowest players on the field. With it set to 0, the game is wide open and way too fast. The default is 50 and still way too wide open. Lowering this slows it down a bit. In Madden the right setting has been between 75 and 95 for the last few years. So I tried 95 and wasn’t getting quite enough separation. Even passing yards per attempt were too low at 95, averaging around 6.5 yards per pass attempt. At 85, I’ve been getting closer to where the sim results are. The sim results were around 8.5 yards per pass attempt on average. I got that number by recording season long stats from all 134 teams. 85 is still a hair low, but it’s better. You could likely get away with going up 75, I just prefer it to be a little slower than that.


            Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

            Comment

            • tessl
              All Star
              • Apr 2007
              • 5648

              #7
              Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

              Originally posted by Mcgibblets82
              This lowers the amount of distance between the fastest and slowest players on the field. With it set to 0, the game is wide open and way too fast. The default is 50 and still way too wide open. Lowering this slows it down a bit. In Madden the right setting has been between 75 and 95 for the last few years. So I tried 95 and wasn’t getting quite enough separation. Even passing yards per attempt were too low at 95, averaging around 6.5 yards per pass attempt. At 85, I’ve been getting closer to where the sim results are. The sim results were around 8.5 yards per pass attempt on average. I got that number by recording season long stats from all 134 teams. 85 is still a hair low, but it’s better. You could likely get away with going up 75, I just prefer it to be a little slower than that.


              Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
              I'm a bit confused. My path to success in NCAA 14 was to recruit speed. What number is neutral with player attributes being accurately reflected?

              Comment

              • Mcgibblets82
                Rookie
                • Sep 2017
                • 482

                #8
                Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

                Originally posted by tessl
                I'm a bit confused. My path to success in NCAA 14 was to recruit speed. What number is neutral with player attributes being accurately reflected?

                Depends on who you ask. Like most sliders, we’ve never been given a clear explanation on that from EA.

                There’s a popular thread in the Madden forums about 95 speed threshold being the speed setting that the devs designed to be true to real life. It’s a good read if you ever get time to read it.

                What I can tell you for certain is that in my test dynasty that I gathered the sim results from, average pass yards per attempt was 8.6 yards per pass attempt. At 85 speed threshold I’m averaging between 8 and 9 yards per pass attempt.

                At 95 speed threshold, I’m averaging between 7 and 8 yards per pass attempt. This is why I settled on 85.


                Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                Comment

                • tessl
                  All Star
                  • Apr 2007
                  • 5648

                  #9
                  Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

                  Originally posted by Mcgibblets82
                  Depends on who you ask. Like most sliders, we’ve never been given a clear explanation on that from EA.

                  There’s a popular thread in the Madden forums about 95 speed threshold being the speed setting that the devs designed to be true to real life. It’s a good read if you ever get time to read it.

                  What I can tell you for certain is that in my test dynasty that I gathered the sim results from, average pass yards per attempt was 8.6 yards per pass attempt. At 85 speed threshold I’m averaging between 8 and 9 yards per pass attempt.

                  At 95 speed threshold, I’m averaging between 7 and 8 yards per pass attempt. This is why I settled on 85.


                  Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                  Thanks for the reply. You obviously have spent a lot of time on this topic.

                  Comment

                  • Mcgibblets82
                    Rookie
                    • Sep 2017
                    • 482

                    #10
                    Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

                    Originally posted by tessl
                    Thanks for the reply. You obviously have spent a lot of time on this topic.

                    Just have spent countless hours gathering data and testing. And reading a whole bunch on these forums lol.

                    Just hoping I can help some other folks get some enjoyment from coach mode.


                    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                    Comment

                    • miamikb2001
                      Pro
                      • Feb 2008
                      • 792

                      #11
                      Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

                      Originally posted by Mcgibblets82
                      Just have spent countless hours gathering data and testing. And reading a whole bunch on these forums lol.

                      Just hoping I can help some other folks get some enjoyment from coach mode.


                      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                      I appreciate all the effort bro


                      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                      Giants
                      49ers
                      Hurricanes
                      Warriors
                      Sharks

                      Comment

                      • BungerHenry
                        Rookie
                        • Jul 2004
                        • 98

                        #12
                        Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

                        Originally posted by Mcgibblets82
                        Just have spent countless hours gathering data and testing. And reading a whole bunch on these forums lol.

                        Just hoping I can help some other folks get some enjoyment from coach mode.


                        Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                        I for one, greatly appreciate the work you've done.

                        Comment

                        • Mcgibblets82
                          Rookie
                          • Sep 2017
                          • 482

                          #13
                          Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

                          Thanks guys


                          Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                          Comment

                          • tessl
                            All Star
                            • Apr 2007
                            • 5648

                            #14
                            Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

                            Originally posted by Mcgibblets82
                            Just have spent countless hours gathering data and testing. And reading a whole bunch on these forums lol.

                            Just hoping I can help some other folks get some enjoyment from coach mode.


                            Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                            I'm on the fence - considering returning the game for store credit. I appreciate your work but I want a game that plays realistically and not one that matches the sim games.

                            If I can figure out how to make the QB pull the ball down and run with it I might try that. Great game but the dozens of slider threads are proof of gameplay problems and the user QB issues in this mode are frustrating. If I thought it would be patched I'd keep the game for sure but I doubt that will happen.

                            Comment

                            • Mcgibblets82
                              Rookie
                              • Sep 2017
                              • 482

                              #15
                              Re: McGibblets CFB25 Dynasty Coach Mode Sliders

                              Originally posted by tessl
                              I'm on the fence - considering returning the game for store credit. I appreciate your work but I want a game that plays realistically and not one that matches the sim games.

                              If I can figure out how to make the QB pull the ball down and run with it I might try that. Great game but the dozens of slider threads are proof of gameplay problems and the user QB issues in this mode are frustrating. If I thought it would be patched I'd keep the game for sure but I doubt that will happen.

                              I mean if you just want to do a play now game with realistic stats, bump the game clock up to 15 minutes and roll with it.

                              But if you do that for dynasty games, you’ll end up 1st in the country in all offensive stats and dead last in all defensive stats.

                              This is the reasoning for matching sim results. But if the game isn’t what we’re hoping for, I wouldn’t blame you for trying to get your money back. Hope you find a way to enjoy it


                              Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                              Comment

                              Working...