Can someone help with ratings/attributes for players on my all time teams on Madden23

[Lionsfan032897]

Are there any pro football historians out there who are good at calculating ratings and coming up with attributes for players who would be willing to help me with the ratings and attributes for my all-time teams for Madden 23? The rosters for my all-time teams are probably the most comprehensive rosters anyone has ever created. For instance I have 165 players on my all-time Detroit Lions roster. I've got players going all the way back to the early 1930's when they were the Portsmouth Spartans. I know the limit is 75 players. Whoever doesn't make the cut I'm just going to make a free agent. I'm not going to have the same players on more than one team. For example Tom Brady is just going to be on the Patriots and Peyton Manning is just going to be on the Colts, because that's where their greatest successes were. I would like to base the players ratings on specific seasons. For example I have Barry Sanders set at 6 years experience so I want to base his ratings on what he did in the 1994 season. My rosters will be on spreadsheets on Google Sheets with columns for the ratings and attributes. If anyone can help me then please e-mail me at [email protected]

[doncropper]

I will be anxiously awaiting your roster ......... Good Luck going forward. Wish I could help but have no clue how to rate players.

[Phantom Fighter]

I would love to see this roster for madden 24. I hated 23 before my 10 hour trial ran out so never bought it. Either way I would be able to help with ratings.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Madden08PCgmr]

Quote: Originally Posted by Lionsfan032897

I'm not going to have the same players on more than one team.

Peyton Manning had his best seasons statistically in Denver. Same with Charles Woodson in Green Bay. Reggie White retired as the Packers AND Eagles all-time sack leader.

Deion Sanders best season hands down was 1994, his only season with the 9ers. Randy Moss, '07 as well.

A case can be made that Tom Brady is the greatest QB in Bucs franchise history.

I don't see what the big deal is having duplicate players on All-Time teams.

.. I thought the MUT ratings for the all-time players were pretty accurate, personally. (but keep in mind 17-18 was the last time I was active)

This site has Madden ratings going all the way back to PS2. We all know what a punching bag default EA rosters are, but it might be a good resource for you. https://maddenratings.weebly.com/

[Phantom Fighter]

Since there have been so many players in history no duplicates is fine to me. However good points have been made. I would say if you want Deion Sanders rated as what he did for his career, he should be a Falcon. Although he only started two less games as a Cowboy so really you can choose. But if you just want players based on a single season then you can really choose whatever you want. Meaning Randy Moss could be a Patriot based on 2007 or a Viking based on 1998 or a Raider if you just hate the man and want his ratings to suffer.

I guess the clarification needed is this an all time roster of greatest seasons (Deion 94 as a 49er) or is it to reflect all time franchise teams (ie Randy Moss is a Viking)


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports