Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

[dghustla]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

Yeah? I know people don't like the robotic throwing, but what's up with the drop back?

No technical issue with the drop backs, i was just pointing out that the animation appeared to be the same, for those who were hoping that they added some new variations or signature styles. It could be coming at a later date as we know the biggest reveals are at least a month away.

[Skyboxer]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

I'd kill for a new passing system.
Something new. Keep the way it is for those that like it but for the love of God give us some options.

Can't wait to see some real video of an actual game being played by a user.
that will show a lot.

[RandyBass]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

I failed before... But I am different now...

A not so subtle message there.

I like that they are working on defense and all, but if there still is no pass interference does it even matter?

Also, that JJ Watt club move seemed a bit excessive, with the offensive lineman going flying.

I failed before... But I am different now...

Yeah, new marketing campaign.

[Mike Lowery]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

I know people don't like this guy (understandably so) but he's on point when it comes to Madden.

http://youtu.be/5rLTmAs89do

[Only1LT]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

I'd kill for a new passing system.
Something new. Keep the way it is for those that like it but for the love of God give us some options.

Can't wait to see some real video of an actual game being played by a user.
that will show a lot.

I was with you all the way until you said keep it as is, as an option lol. Still liked the post.

[Mike Lowery]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

Yeah? I know people don't like the robotic throwing, but what's up with the drop back?

You mean besides the fact that they look nothing like real life and have been the same for the past 10 years?

This is how it should be

http://youtu.be/938f14uJhVw

[MajorSupreme]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

You mean besides the fact that they look nothing like real life and have been the same for the past 10 years?

This is how it should be
http://youtu.be/938f14uJhVw

Fair point, that would be great to see.

[Scratchboi]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

Just curious, where's you 14m number coming from? I assumed 2004 when Madden 05 and NFL 2K5 released, but those two games combined didn't sell 10m according to VGChartz and most certainly there was some crossover in sales between the two games; I know I bought both.

I tried to send you this is a PM but I'm not allowed. A quick check over at ign.com one of the largest online gaming sites around, essentially reproduces the concerns that most have stared on this very forum. I bring this up because I keep getting this reoccurring theme that OS only represents 01% of Madden fans. I think you grossly underestimate this forum, or the state of the fan base in general.

It has to be at least alarming to EA that their product is met with such underwhelming response throughout most communities wouldn't you agree?

[BezO]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

Oh and if you watch the clip of JJ WATT clubbing the Olineman and ignore him and only watch the Jags QB, drop back animations have not been addressed.

The drop back animation isn't the best, but my conerns with drop back passes are more about the speed/depth of the speed rush vs the QB's drop, depth/angle of the OT's kick step... pocket stuff... and timing of the drop & pass patterns.

And that Watt club is way out of context IMO. D-linemen don't club, at least not with that type of success, during a stationary hand fight. That's a move typically used after getting the o-lineman's momentum going. I grew up watching Reggie White use that move. Never once do I remember him clubbing a 300 lb man off his feet without using his momentum against him.

---------------

When I compare Madden to the great sports titles, NBA 2K & MLB The Show, Madden doesn't fit. Sure you can cheese in 2K and get to the lane easier than real life. You can dunk easier than real life. You might be able to hit HRs at a higher clip in The Show than real life. The Show has some quirks that remind you it's a video game. But in single player modes, or 2 sim players playing, you can make the game look quite realistic, get realistic stats, realistic outcomes, etc. But I'm an offline gamer. Both games might require some slider adjustments, but it's very possible.

With Madden, no matter how sim your style is, no matter what sliders you change, the game will never look real to me. Fundamental football AI is not present. Key animations/interactions are missing. The timing of many animations are off. With the best intentions, Madden is not capable of looking anything like what I expect. These are things I notice immediately when looking at even the shortest trailers.

[vpizzle28]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

I liked the video. Call me crazy, but I mostly play online with a couple of friends, and then Ranked.

These are the 2 things I want.

Fairplay back!
CB vs. WR interation.

Also a Highlight stick for WR. That's all.

[SamuraiX]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

I liked the video. Call me crazy, but I mostly play online with a couple of friends, and then Ranked.

These are the 2 things I want.

Fairplay back!
CB vs. WR interation.

Also a Highlight stick for WR. That's all.

Amen to the cb wr interaction, hopefully them comes along with the improved man and zone d.

[Hooe]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

It has to be at least alarming to EA that their product is met with such underwhelming response throughout most communities wouldn't you agree?

Not really. It's the internet. Everyone complains about everything.

The people complaining aren't in EA's primary target audience (competitive online gamers) anyway. The ones complaining online aren't the ones responsible for EA's 90% year-over-year increase in Ultimate Team sales.

[jaxson_mateo]

I had hope ... I really did. But I knew EA would be trying fool all of us again. EA better hope 2k doesn't every launch an NFL game. The second they announce it I am pre-ordering my 2k version and I will never look back.

[BezO]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

You mean besides the fact that they look nothing like real life and have been the same for the past 10 years?

This is how it should be
http://youtu.be/938f14uJhVw

Yeah, see the depth of the drop and depth of the OTs? Edge rush timing fits with that as well. The timing of the patterns fit. The timing of bump & run fit. When plays work, more times than not, they work for the same reason they do in real life.

When folks reference 2K football, they're talking about things like this. It wasn't perfect. Running animations improved with 2K8, but 2K5 running animations sucked, for example. But enough of the fundamentals were there that you could play Football if you wanted.

[CaliDude916]

Re: Madden NFL 15 Official Trailer, Ultimate Edition Details and a Few Screenshots

Gonna need to see more at E3, but what I saw in this video, I was not impressed. Graphics looked great, but aside from that, everything looked the same. Same animations and no equipment updates (still no lipguard mouthpiece; Lynch, Gore, Forte, Demaryius Thomas).