I wouldn't say that. CJ had one amazing year and one good one. AP has consistently been elite each year he's played. I'd like to see CJ prove he can have another great season before he is ranked above AP.
Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
Collapse
Recommended Videos
Collapse
X
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
I wouldn't say that. CJ had one amazing year and one good one. AP has consistently been elite each year he's played. I'd like to see CJ prove he can have another great season before he is ranked above AP. -
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
A.P.'s stats his first 2 years totals 3,101yards 22td's 13fums.C.J's stats his first 2 years 3,234yards 23td's 4fums.Men lie women lie numbers don't Chris Johnson is one of the top 3 runningbacks in the nfl. Just because he hasn't been in as long doesn't mean he's not deserving of that 99 alls that means is his THAT good.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
I would rate CJ and AP both 97.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
I think no player should be 99 until they are incapable in improving in their game such as Peyton Manning maybe even Jared Allen. Darrell Revis, CJ, and AP can only get better being so young. What happens if AP cuts down his fumbles and Revis gets more picks? How can they be better in Maddem already having the MAX OVR?Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
I think no player should be 99 until they are incapable in improving in their game such as Peyton Manning maybe even Jared Allen. Darrell Revis, CJ, and AP can only get better being so young. What happens if AP cuts down his fumbles and Revis gets more picks? How can they be better in Maddem already having the MAX OVR?Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
The thing is, no one deserves a 99 besides Peyton. I think the top players should be something like this
99 P. Manning
96 T. Brady
96 A. Johnson
95 A. Peterson
94 J. Allen
94. D Revis
94 N. Asomugha
93 C. Johnson
93 D. Brees
92 R. Lewis
92 L. Fletcher“No one is more hated than he who speaks the truth.”
― PlatoComment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
Personally you don't want to know what i think about manning especially being a titans fan.Seriously manning deserves to be 99 but so do ALL the other players who got that rating as well.He's the best qb but the best player at their position also deserves that rating too.qb's aren't the ONLY ones who deserve 99 ratings.Everyone here knows just because you play with manning doesn't mean your going to win.99 doesn't mean "best player" it just means that what they do they do great.So,does EVERYONE here think manning is the best player in madden or just the best qb?Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
Personally you don't want to know what i think about manning especially being a titans fan.Seriously manning deserves to be 99 but so do ALL the other players who got that rating as well.He's the best qb but the best player at their position also deserves that rating too.qb's aren't the ONLY ones who deserve 99 ratings.Everyone here knows just because you play with manning doesn't mean your going to win.99 doesn't mean "best player" it just means that what they do they do great.So,does EVERYONE here think manning is the best player in madden or just the best qb?Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
Even if someone is rated 99, if he improves, they could still improve certain attributes. Your overall would be maxed, but not your attributes. So there is still room for improvement until all your attributes are full.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
Personally you don't want to know what i think about manning especially being a titans fan.Seriously manning deserves to be 99 but so do ALL the other players who got that rating as well.He's the best qb but the best player at their position also deserves that rating too.qb's aren't the ONLY ones who deserve 99 ratings.Everyone here knows just because you play with manning doesn't mean your going to win.99 doesn't mean "best player" it just means that what they do they do great.So,does EVERYONE here think manning is the best player in madden or just the best qb?Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
Manning and Brady have had long careers, and have both established themselves as two of the greatest quarterbacks of all time. Just because you think your team's runningback is the greatest of all time after two years doesn't mean the less-biased fans of other teams have to agree. Let's have the "is Chris Johnson the best ever" discussion in maybe 10 more years.
Carolina Panthers - NC State Wolfpack - Charlotte Hornets - Brisbane Roar FC - VfB StuttgartComment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
Manning and Brady have had long careers, and have both established themselves as two of the greatest quarterbacks of all time. Just because you think your team's runningback is the greatest of all time after two years doesn't mean the less-biased fans of other teams have to agree. Let's have the "is Chris Johnson the best ever" discussion in maybe 10 more years.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
This is true... So who out of the 99's would you say is the most highest rated player? if it went up to the 100's, who would it be and around what rating would he be? 110?Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
Ratings do not stem from players that have done it for years. If that is the case then Champ Bailey would be a 99, Favre 99, Moss 99, Woodson 99, Dawkins 99, LT 99, etc. Chris Johinson tore it up last season and had one of the best single seasons of any RB in NFL history! He certainly deserves a 99. IMO I am a Dolphins fan.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans
I agree. I would only rate Brady a 93 right now, although I think he is one of the top 3 QBs of all time. I just think CJ is no where near "all time greats" talk quite yet.
I would say the only player that deserves above a 99 rating would be Revis and he probably deserves a 102. I thought Fitz deserved about a 101 after the Cardinals playoff run, but he has dropped down to a 98 in my book. And I had Tony Gonzalez at a 102 at one point but he has dropped down to a 97 in my book.Comment
Comment