Madden NFL 10 Ratings: Top 10 by Position (ESPN Videogames)

[steelers1]

Roethlisberger has a career passer rating of 89.4 (9th all time). He has a career completion % of 62.4 (14th all time), has thrown 101 TDs to 69 INTs and is 7th all time in yards/attempt. He is 51-20 as a starter in the regular season and is 8-2 with an 87.2 rating in the playoffs. He is 22-4 against teams in his division in the regular season (24-4 total). He has set many Steelers single game and single season records, and also holds nearly all of the efficiency records (rating, comp %, ypam etc) and is 2nd only to Terry Bradshaw in most other areas (wins, TDs, yards, etc).

Everybody has their opinions, but comparing Roethlisberger to Trent Dilfer or Kerry Collins or any other game manager is ridiculous. And the 85 Bears had Jim McMahon, who was a pretty good QB and could have been really good if he hadn't got injured in 86.

[shotgun styles]

Quote: Originally Posted by steelers1

Roethlisberger has a career passer rating of 89.4 (9th all time). He has a career completion % of 62.4 (14th all time), has thrown 101 TDs to 69 INTs and is 7th all time in yards/attempt. He is 51-20 as a starter in the regular season and is 8-2 with an 87.2 rating in the playoffs. He is 22-4 against teams in his division in the regular season (24-4 total). He has set many Steelers single game and single season records, and also holds nearly all of the efficiency records (rating, comp %, ypam etc) and is 2nd only to Terry Bradshaw in most other areas (wins, TDs, yards, etc). Everybody has their opinions, but comparing Roethlisberger to Trent Dilfer or Kerry Collins or any other game manager is ridiculous. And the 85 Bears had Jim McMahon, who was a pretty good QB and could have been really good if he hadn't got injured in 86.

Like I said, you can't measure a player by statistics alone.

[steelers1]

Quote: Originally Posted by shotgun styles

See, this is what I was on about earlier. You subscribe to this myth that being a great system QB with huge stats makes you a great overall player. I disagree. Manning and Brady have time and time again PROVEN themselves to be physically incabable of making plays when the system breaks down. They curl up and take a sack or throw the ball away. Roethlisberger makes plays when Manning or Brady would be sacked or give up on the play. That counts for something. There is a game that is played between the hash marks that cannot be measured in statistics.

Very well said. This is impossible to explain to most people. It's like when I talked to a guy after the Super Bowl this year who hates the Steelers and the first thing he said was 'Roethlisberger got showed up by Warner.' Statistically... sure. But that's not all that matters.

[Donny_Moore]

James Harrison 97 or 98 OVR. Have no clue why Marketing failed to include him in this list to give to ESPN,

Steelers fans can get their panties out of their you know whats now.

[SouthernBrick]

Hey donny whats up with LT's carry rating? 87 is a bit low for 1 fumble in 2 seasons.

[Glorious Arc]

Quote: Originally Posted by pimpycraig

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3JTXupThgQ tell me if he is.

I hate to just bring up 40 times because they almost mean nothing when it comes to game day speed but Willis was clock at 4.37 at his pro day and I have read reports of 4.51 during his combine. I cant say much one way or the other because I dont watch him play but he truely is a beast statistically speaking.

[stux]

If all these player's everyone has been hyping up so much make the HoF they better start a very large addition now to make room.

Outside that I, as a Bears fan, will agree the Pack fan and continue to believe Big Cry Baby Ben won't remember as one of the best all time unless his Super Bowl ring's thanks to a great team get him there.

I used to to really like the guy. But then after his first major injury and watching the way he handled him self I just can't take the guy seriously. I mean for the size of the guy he sure cries a lot. Every time he got hit he would start complaining to anyone who would listen.

I bet if he was a boxer the first time he got hit hard he would hide behind the ref and start crying asking for protection.

[droopizzle34]

As much as it pains me to give a Steeler some props(go Titans!), Big Ben can be my QB any day. He is the true definition of a scrambling elusive QB: he buys time to PASS,he moves around to PASS....

Mike Vick, Vince Young, take notes.