Madden NFL 10 Ratings: Top 10 by Position (ESPN Videogames)

[Glorious Arc]

Quote: Originally Posted by shotgun styles

WHAT?!!? And you base this fantasy on WHAT? Cassell already PROVED that Brady's big numbers could be replaced by a HIGH SCHOOL QUARTERBACK. Come on man...

A fairly valid point. Cassell put up numbers comparable to Brady before Moss. Brady is a good QB and when he got his new toy aka Moss he put up better numbers then before. Would Brady/Manning be better on another team IDK. No one does. My only beef is that Brady's arm strength currently overrated. It needs to be lowered to 90-92.

Another thing I would like to add right now is Manning could have put up better numbers during his record breaking season. There were several games that they were called off and stopped throwing the ball. How many times during Brady's record breaking season did we see him passing the ball when they were up by 30+ points?

[cha0ss0ldier]

LOL at everyone all over TO.

Right now Roddy White is a better WR then TO...deal with it.

[SoxFan01605]

Quote: Originally Posted by droopizzle34

i don't get the flak, White is a good WR(why didn't he catch all of Mike Vick's passes!!!! ),but I mean why would you compare his numbers to an over the hill T.O's numbers? I'll take T.O in his prime over White any day.

That's not the issue though. I thought it was who should be better now...in terms of ratings.

[larryfoot5050]

No Defensive MVP? James Harrison got robbed

[droopizzle34]

Quote: Originally Posted by SoxFan01605

That's not the issue though. I thought it was who should be better now...in terms of ratings.

good point,i stand corrected.

[edwing]

Quote: Originally Posted by Glorious Arc

How many times during Brady's record breaking season did we see him passing the ball when they were up by 30+ points?

True, but it was fun to watch.

As for Brady's ratings, i would go 89 power, 96 short, 93 medium, 90 deep, and his speed could go down by about 3-4 points.

[WFColonel56]

Quote: Originally Posted by droopizzle34

somebody go to the game tape and tell me how many double teams Roddy White had to face while he caught those passes. Man you guys crack me up. Numbers aren't everything...if thats the case, like someone SAID on another post, Charlie Batch should be in the HOF over Drew Brees and D-Mac: numbers-----Batch 2 rings, Brees and DMac 0. He's better right? LMAO

OK, DAL had 2 number 1 WRs..(some say, not me ).....and a lights out number 3 WR....and an ok running game....(and defenses sometimes had to spy ROMO with LBS)

VS

ATL
Roddy white and nobody else.....and a very good run game....Plus White was coming off a good year so teams knew what they were facing.


lets see who got doubled more hmmmmmmmmm....... RODDY WHITE.......And no i dont have the game tape but common sense should lead you to the right direction.

Thats the main reason that brought up average yards per catch.......

[Hova57]

I just wished that bcv would carry more weight. if your running back doesn't have high rating he should have hard time with cutback lanes. same for punt and kick returners, wr ,te and some safeties.

as far as westbrook speed goes when he's not hurt their is dbs that can't cover him please. don't hate