Madden NFL 10 Ratings: Top 10 by Position (ESPN Videogames)

[stux]

I personally think Manning is the best QB in the league. When he retires he will have beaten all of Farve's records other then INTs. Unless, he retires early.

[Glorious Arc]

Quote: Originally Posted by shotgun styles

Manning is a more accomplished passer. Moss changed everything. Remember, Moss put Culpepper and a post-retirement Cunnigham in the Pro-Bowl. He's a QB maker.

Still Brady has maintained a 60%+ accuracy before the Moss effect. I know part of this is because he is more elusive/mobile then manning.

You are right though. Manning almost has passed twice as much as Brady. I wonder how good Manning would be with Moss...

[Glorious Arc]

Quote: Originally Posted by nepatriotsfan

dont forget that manning had marvin harrison his entire career

You really did just prove his point. Harrison required you to throw accurately to him and thread the needle to get him the ball. He is amazing but he also had an amazing QB.

I could score 20 touchdowns in the NFL with Moss lol. Just throw the ball up in the general area and Moss will almost always outperform the DB for the ball.

[marcoyk]

How does Larry Fitz have only 89 speed. He made a slant route into like a 40 yard TD run (I'm not sure about the exact distance of the run). 89?! And I don't really get the idea that Andre Johnson is that fast when watching him play. 94? Regardless I can't wait for this game. haha

[Derrville]

I dont think anything will be changed.

Bradys TP has been like that for a while and despite basically EVERYONE disagreeing with it, it remains the same.

[shotgun styles]

Quote: Originally Posted by Sanchez_Mareno

Cassel was nowhere near as good, especially early. Brady has proved through the years he doesnt need help. Years where Troy Brown(albeit a club legend but declining at the time) and Reche Caldwell etc were his weapons

And he wasn't throwing for 4000 yards and 50 TDs back then either, now was he?

I remember a game where he had FIVE COMPLETIONS and won the game! Those were great TEAMS that Brady just had to keep out of trouble and on schedule. The kicker won all three AFC Championship games and all three Superbowls.

Quote: Originally Posted by Glorious Arc

Still Brady has maintained a 60%+ accuracy before the Moss effect. I know part of this is because he is more elusive/mobile then manning. You are right though. Manning almost has passed twice as much as Brady. I wonder how good Manning would be with Moss...

I'm not saying Brady sucked. Not at all. I'm just saying that he was not asked to do much during those Superbowl years other than manage the game, and didn't start blowing the doors off statistically until Moss arrived.

[Sanchez_Mareno]

Quote: Originally Posted by shotgun styles

And he wasn't throwing for 4000 yards and 50 TDs back then either, now was he? I remember a game where he had FIVE COMPLETIONS and won the game! Those were great TEAMS that Brady just had to keep out of trouble and on schedule. The kicker won all three AFC Championship games and all three Superbowls. I'm not saying Brady sucked. Not at all. I'm just saying that he was not asked to do much during those Superbowl years other than manage the game, and didn't start blowing the doors off statistically until Moss arrived.

He was winning SB's.... thats all

[shotgun styles]

Quote: Originally Posted by Sanchez_Mareno

He was winning SB's.... thats all

His TEAM was winning Superbowls. His KICKER was winning Superbowls. Tom was along for the ride.