My band is expanding its song lineup, and I get to pick a new song for us to do. I've narrowed it down to four of them...help me pick.

1. Pinball Wizard by The Who
2. Mrs. Robinson by Simon and Garfunkel
3. Magic Carpet Ride by Steppenwolf
4. Spirit in the Sky by Norman Greenbaum

I think most people will know and get into Magin carpet ride

Gotta go with Mrs. Robinson. I don't know what kind of band you have, but I'm thinking that's the one you could have the most fun with and turn it into your own.

What, no "Sweet Child O' Mine"?

Spirit in the Sky FTW

Voted Mrs. Robinson because it's multiple choice. But it were fill in the blank, I'd have gone with Lost in Your Eyes by Debbie Gibson.

Come on. It's gotta be Pinball Wizard.

Well, it's a '60's pop band -- we play songs like Pleasant Valley Sunday, Kicks, and Incense and Peppermints. If you want a real good idea of what we sound like, you can check out our website -- www.oldschoolrocknroll.com. My problem is that I think we'd pull off all of these songs well, and I like them all. We just don't have room in our setlist for all of them.

Pinball Wizard.

After listening to the band, I'd say Mrs. Robinson.