http://www.mensjournal.com/feature/0312/guymovies.html

Discuss

Die Hard at #4 may be just a tad high...

If anyone just has a straight list, please post it.

Fight Club at 20 is the firs t movie I wouldnt even entain to be on a list like this. matrix would not make the list, but I would at least talk about it.

No StarWars ???

"Certain actors recur frequently. Al Pacino (twice in the top ten), McQueen (twice), Clint Eastwood (three times), Paul Newman (three), Robert De Niro (three), Bill Murray (two). "

Mens Journal obviously does not like John Wayne.

Sands of Iwo Jima should be a top 10, IMHO.

Originally posted by Darkiller
No StarWars ???

"Guy Movies"

I'd say I agree with about 2/3-3/4 of the movies, but I'd probably change the order.

Die Hard is becoming my favorite movie of all time.

Terminator in the top 10? Everyone knows that T2 was better.

Originally posted by pskov
Terminator in the top 10? Everyone knows that T2 was better.

gasp

1 DIRTY HARRY 1972
2 THE GODFATHER 1972
3 SCARFACE 1983
4 DIE HARD 1988
5 THE TERMINATOR 1984
6 THE ROAD WARRIOR 1981
7 THE DIRTY DOZEN 1967
8 THE MATRIX 1999
9 CADDYSHACK 1980
10 ROCKY 1976
11 FULL METAL JACKET 1987
12 DR. NO 1962
13 THE KILLER 1989
14 RAGING BULL 1980
15 BULLITT 1968
16 ENTER THE DRAGON 1973
17 APOCALYPSE NOW 1979
18 GOODFELLAS 1990
19 RESERVOIR DOGS 1992
20 FIGHT CLUB 1999
21 THE USUAL SUSPECTS 1995
22 BLAZING SADDLES 1974
23 THE WILD BUNCH 1969
24 THE MALTESE FALCON 1941
25 UNFORGIVEN 1992
26 THE SEVEN SAMURAI 1954
27 DINER 1982
28 THE BIG LEBOWSKI 1998
29 SHAFT 1971
30 48 HRS 1982
31 THE SEARCHERS 1956
32 PLATOON 1986
33 ANIMAL HOUSE 1978
34 THE GOOD, THE BAD, AND THE UGLY 1966
35 THE LONGEST YARD 1974
36 BLADE 1998
37 STRIPES 1981
38 NORTH DALLAS FORTY 1979
39 THE UNTOUCHABLES 1987
40 THE GREAT ESCAPE 1963
41 THE THREE STOOGES
42 THE HUSTLER 1961
43 SLAP SHOT 1977
44 THE FRENCH CONNECTION 1971
45 OFFICE SPACE 1999
46 EASY RIDER 1969
47 DAZED AND CONFUSED 1993
48 THE BRIDGE ON THE RIVER KWAI 1957
49 COOL HAND LUKE 1967
50 FLETCH 1985

thanks

I'm not much for movies, but incredibly, I've only seen 10 of these movies from beginning to end. I've seen parts of about 20 of them, and the rest I either haven't seen, don't want to see, or never heard of.

They forgot:

Alien/Aliens

Pulp Fiction?

Lethal Weapon

The collected works of Tom Cruise (A Few Good Men, Top Gun, all the right moves)

The Magnificent Seven

Patton

Lonesome Dove (maybe number 1 if it were actually a movie)

Braveheart, shouldn't this be near the top of the list?

Stalag 17

Saving Private Ryan (is this one too realistic?)

Gladiator

Sleepless in Seattle (just checking if you are paying attention)

:There is no spoon" was the best line from The Matrix? Are you kidding me?

Originally posted by judicial clerk
They forgot:

Alien/Aliens

Pulp Fiction?

Lethal Weapon

Saving Private Ryan (is this one too realistic?)

Gladiator

Agree. I was expecting SPR to be No.1

Originally posted by judicial clerk
Sleepless in Seattle (just checking if you are paying attention)

You had me at Tom Cruise. :eek:

First Blood did not make this list and office space did?

Where's Hercules in New York?

I would've had to include Blade Runner in this list.

I've seen like 5

Worst. List. Ever.

Any list of guy movies that doesn't put Caddyshack at No. 1 is just ridiculous. It is clearly the most-quoted and most-revered movie of almost every guy I know.

No offense, but I'd call this the list of Best Dumb Guy Movies of all time. Sure, there are some good films in there by accident, but these seem like the chocies of a 42-year-old alcoholic.

Star Wars not on the list? Hey, I've been to the midnight screenings of the last two films, and I didn't see too many chicks there. They may be geeks, but they are guys.

Muscle head list perhaps?

"Why don't you guys go down to the gym and pump each other."

Originally posted by kcchief19
They may be geeks, but they are guys. :D

I've seen 16 of them all the way through. A few others that I have not seen and really really need to(The Godfather(*gasp* I know, how could I have not seen it yet)).

Magnificient Seven is covered by the Seven Samauri I assume.

I would have also expected to see Saving Private Ryan on the list. I think Lethal Weapon also belongs...

Originally posted by Fritz
Fight Club at 20 is the firs t movie I wouldnt even entain to be on a list like this. matrix would not make the list, but I would at least talk about it.

Fight Club belongs on the list. Should be in the top 10.

Originally posted by pskov
Agree. I was expecting SPR to be No.1

SPR is a good film, but still over-rated.

The Unforgiven is way too low on that list. Best western of all time.

I agree with Road Warrior, Matrix, Fight Club, Die Hard, etc.

I'd like to know about a few movies - did they miss the list altogether, were they close, did editors debate them?

A Clockwork Orange? Pulp Fiction? GHOSTBUSTERS!?!?!

Seriously, any movie list that doesn't include Ghostbusters is questionable in my mind. How could you include comedies such as Fletch, Blazing Saddles and Stripes (showing that they did include comedies), but not include Ghostbusters, which is better than any of those three movies.

Ah well.

-Anxiety

Originally posted by judicial clerk


Braveheart, shouldn't this be near the top of the list?



I agree with Gladiator and Stalag 17, great films.

And Braveheart is a great movie, but there is too much love story non-sense to make it a real guy film.

Plus, that movie massacres the historical events and people.

I mean, no bridge at the battle of Stirling Bridge?

And whats up with the English archers only shooting a few bows before the English send the knights in?

Originally posted by Anxiety
I agree with Road Warrior, Matrix, Fight Club, Die Hard, etc.

I'd like to know about a few movies - did they miss the list altogether, were they close, did editors debate them?

A Clockwork Orange? Pulp Fiction? GHOSTBUSTERS!?!?!

Seriously, any movie list that doesn't include Ghostbusters is questionable in my mind. How could you include comedies such as Fletch, Blazing Saddles and Stripes (showing that they did include comedies), but not include Ghostbusters, which is better than any of those three movies.

Ah well.

-Anxiety

A Clockwork Orange is a greta move which could make the list. The book is even better.

Ghostbusters was a good movie, but not better than Stripes or Blazing Saddles. Maybe better than Fletch.

Originally posted by Die Hand die Verletzt
Ghostbusters was a good movie, but not better than Stripes or Blazing Saddles. Maybe better than Fletch.

Blasphemy...maybe you need a refresher course...

I agree with kcchief19......Worst list......While there are great movies listed, they left out a bunch (Old School, Fear and Loathing, Royal Tenenbaums, America History X, Dumb and Dumber, Memento, Super Troopers, Snatch) Those are just off the top of my head. I also agree with most of the movies everyone else has listed. And in my opinong, Fight Club has got to be the greatest movie of all time.

Originally posted by rkmsuf
Blasphemy...maybe you need a refresher course... Obviously he does. It's all ball bearings these days.

Moooooooooooooon River

Originally posted by JimJam19
I agree with kcchief19......Worst list......While there are great movies listed, they left out a bunch (Old School, Fear and Loathing, Royal Tenenbaums, America History X, Dumb and Dumber, Memento, Super Troopers, Snatch) Those are just off the top of my head. I also agree with most of the movies everyone else has listed. And in my opinong, Fight Club has got to be the greatest movie of all time.

Well, I gotta side with the list makers as none of those should be on that list. As for Fight Club being the best movie of all time... uh, no. It's good, not nearly that good.

SI

Slap Shot is WAY too low on that list. That's at least a top 10 "Guy Movie".

Trade me right f-ing now...

I think Se7en has to be near the top 10. And maybe its not a "manly man" movie, but Every guy I know loves the Shawshank Redemption.

I'd vote for

Saving Private Ryan
Se7en
Das Boot
Star Wars

Star Wars and Ghostbusters are not "man movies."

if you are going to include them why not just put in Color Purple and On Golden Pod?

hmmm Tora! Tora! Tora! and Heartbreak Ridge?

The Patriot?

I'm wouldn't say Se7en is a "Guy Movie" either. Most women I know tend to love phsycological thrillers/detective movies.

I have also only seen ten of these, but this pushes me to want to see: Platoon, The Usual Suspects, and all of Animal House.

Damn Shorty, you need to hurry up and turn 17 so you can watch more of the movies.

And while Pulp Fiction is a classic and near the top of my favorites, even my Mom enjoyed it, so there goes the whole guy angle..

Originally posted by Shorty3281
I have also only seen ten of these, but this pushes me to want to see: Platoon, The Usual Suspects, and all of Animal House.

The Usual Suspects should be required viewing for everyone. Go see this now. Feel free to watch it multiple times in the future as well.

Not sure I'd call The Usual Suspects or Pulp Fiction a Guy Movies either. Seems like this site just wanted to put up any movie that's not considered a Chick Flick that they liked.

I know...I'm being picky...

dola,

The Usual Suspects is one of my favorite movies of all time. I agree with JAG, everyone should have to watch it to graduate from high school. :D

No "debbie does dallas"?

Cobra
Invasion USA
Red Dawn

Originally posted by JimJam19
I agree with kcchief19......Worst list......While there are great movies listed, they left out a bunch (Old School, Fear and Loathing, Royal Tenenbaums, America History X, Dumb and Dumber, Memento, Super Troopers, Snatch) Those are just off the top of my head. I also agree with most of the movies everyone else has listed. And in my opinong, Fight Club has got to be the greatest movie of all time.

That's a joke, right? Maybe you and kcchief should look up the definition of a "guy" movie. I'll give you a hint, it rhymes with "nacho". It's about action and adventure and screwball laughs. Metrosexuals need not apply.

I agree some of my choices there dont qualify as "guy" movies, such as Fear and Loathing, Royal Ten and Memento and maybe even Snatch. But Old School, Dumb and Dumber, Super Troopers are classics. How can you argue with "It's powdered sugar.......it's delicous". I would argue that they dont have to be big macho movies to be "guy" movies. The movies I mentioned above have "guy" humor in them. Another movie I forgot about, but it's actually one of my all time favorites is The Rock.

Also now that I think about it, American History X should be striken from the record. That is actually a good, thought provoking movie which anyone can enjoy.

Originally posted by Buccaneer
That's a joke, right? Maybe you and kcchief should look up the definition of a "guy" movie. I'll give you a hint, it rhymes with "nacho". It's about action and adventure and screwball laughs. Metrosexuals need not apply.

hands bucc a medal

Originally posted by LastWhiteSoxFanStanding
Red Dawn

I watched this last night for the first time in a long time. That movie's nuts and I don't think I realized how nuts the first time I watched it. There were so many funny moments on the unintentional comedy scale! It's every redneck's textbook for raising kids and fending off foreign invasions.

SI

I would argue that they dont have to be big macho movies to be "guy" movies.

If they are not macho then they have to be Mel Brooks type or slapstick movies. Macho dominates though.